Health and wellness emails delivered to your gym members and leads 52 weeks a year!

Your Email List Is Already FULL of Opportunity!

Are You Taking Advantage of It?

Hey there! I’m Amy.

Anytime Fitness Owner | Functional Medicine Practitioner | Wellness Writer

If you’re anything like I was, you have a list of members, former members, and prospects you know you should be staying connected with.

The problem? Between running a gym, managing staff, handling sales, putting out fires, and everything else that comes with ownership, creating thoughtful email content every week tends to fall to the bottom of the list.

That’s exactly why I created Connection Collective.

I own an Anytime Fitness too, and I started these emails in my own club because I wanted a better way to stay connected with people without constantly sending another sales pitch.

Instead, I started sharing helpful, research-backed health and wellness information people could actually use.

And something pretty amazing happened.

People responded. Leads joined!

Helpful Content. Real Connection. Measurable Revenue.

The idea is simple: when you consistently provide useful information, you give members another reason to value your gym, AND you give prospects a reason to keep opening your emails until they’re ready to take the next step.

And some of those prospects have been sitting in the database much longer than you might think.

In one recent month, across 8 participating gyms:

81 new memberships were attributed to the emails.

That worked out to an average of:

10 new memberships per club

$444 in new monthly recurring dues

More than $6,600 in annual membership value

Approximately $33 in projected revenue value for every $1 invested

The average age of the lead - 14 months! That means that these people needed consistent, no pressure nurturing before they finally decided to come in to join!

Average time from reading the email to joining - less than two days.

One owner has generated 101 new memberships in his first 3 months sending out our emails across his two clubs, adding $3,546 in monthly dues plus $2,098 collected at signup.

That’s what made me realize how much untapped value may already be sitting inside the lists we’ve spent years, and a lot of money, building.

Gym marketing has become heavily focused on finding the next lead through social media, paid ads, and lead-generation campaigns. And there’s absolutely a place for those things.

But we often spend so much time looking for new people that we forget about the hundreds, or more likely thousands, of people who have already raised their hand at some point.

They visited your website.

They toured your club.

They joined before.

They entered a promotion.

They asked about pricing.

They already know who you are.

They simply haven't joined yet.

Connection Collective helps you stay meaningfully connected with those people through consistent wellness education that builds familiarity and trust over time.

Because sometimes you don’t need another lead. You need a better way to stay connected with the ones you already have.

Every week, I create engaging, easy-to-understand wellness content built around topics your members and prospects actually care about —things like metabolic health, recovery, sleep, healthy aging, hormones, nutrition, movement, and longevity.

I handle the writing, research, formatting, setup, and delivery through your Club OS lists. You Stay Connected. And You Don't Lift a Finger!

Your club gets consistent, professional communication without adding another task to your team’s already-full plate.

And unlike traditional promotional emails, the goal isn’t to push people into buying something every week.

It’s to be useful.

To educate.

To stay relevant.

And to make sure that when someone finally decides, I’m ready to do something about my health, your gym is already familiar to them.

Created by a Gym Owner Who Understands the Problem

I’m Amy Paolinelli, an Anytime Fitness owner in Henderson, Nevada.

I also have a Master’s degree in Psychology, a Master’s degree in Nutrition and Functional Medicine, and I’m currently working on my doctorate in Oriental Medicine and Acupuncture.

Connection Collective brings those worlds together: understanding people, understanding health, and understanding what it’s actually like to run a gym.

I didn’t create this as another marketing agency selling gym owners more marketing.

I created it because it worked in my own club, and I realized it could genuinely help other owners too. We've spent years and loads of money building the lists we already have. Let's make sure to do something meaningful with them!

Provide more value to your members.

Stay connected with your prospects.

Keep old leads engaged.

Build trust before asking for the sale.

And do it without having to add another task to your plate, or another high cost to work into your budget.

Our Numbers Speak for Themselves!

Email Open Rate: 43% (more than double the industry average)

New Memberships from Emails: 11 per month

Sale Age From Message: 2 Days

Length of Membership: 16 months

*These numbers are monthly averages over a 3 month period

Choose From Our Packages

Connection Collective

Single Club Membership

$199/month


  • 4 Weekly Health and Wellness Emails

  • Input and Scheduling of all emails into your Club OS (you don't lift a finger!)

Connection Collective

Multiple Gym Membership

$199/mo for 1st club

$100/month each additional location.


  • 4 Weekly Health and Wellness Emails

  • Input and Scheduling of all emails into your Club OS (you don't lift a finger!)

What Gym Members And Leads Have To Say:

Thank you Amy. Your routine newsletters are interesting and I appreciate getting them.

Alma

Thank you Amy!!! Good Stuff!!!

Michael Martin

Thank you so much for all of this helpful information! I look forward to these emails every week!

Jenn

Hi Amy,

I made that Brussels Sprouts recipe a few weeks ago. It was actually pretty good. Just thought I’d let you know. Thank you,

- Jacqueline Claire

Hello Amy! I've so enjoyed these weekly emails! Have you thought of seeing if other Anytime owners want to send them out to their clients? Just a thought. ;) I hope you're well xo!

- Eva

We write the emails — you grow the gym!

Do you want to grow your business? Yes or No

Contact Us

© 2026 Connection Collective